Create a Fabric Covered Button Set for Your Cardigan
A fabric covered button set gives a plain cardigan a considered, handmade finish. The circles can echo a lining, repeat a floral print from the cuffs, or pick up one colour from a striped knit. Because they are made as a group rather than one at a time, every button can share the same scale, fabric grain and neat reverse, creating a detail that makes an everyday layer feel personal.
Start with the cardigan, not the blank drawer. A close-fitting adult cardigan may only need five or six buttons, while a longline version might call for eight or ten. Check the existing buttonholes, measure their spacing and decide whether you are replacing the original closures or making a new opening. Preserving a well-worn favourite while changing its visual character is one of the pleasures of making a new set.
The process is simpler than the polished result suggests. Each blank needs a fabric circle, a little adhesive and careful pressing before it joins the cardigan. Most of the work happens on a small board beside an iron, making this a useful weekend project for a beginner or a satisfying batch to produce alongside a larger garment.
Local sourcing is part of the pleasure. Op shops across Australia often have jars of buttons and remnant bins, while Saturday craft markets in Melbourne, Adelaide and Sydney mix offcuts with handmade wares. A cardigan made in a humid Brisbane home can use lightweight cotton, whereas one layered through a chilly Melbourne winter may suit a denser fabric with more body.
Plan the Size and Count of the Set
A useful first decision is whether to cover the existing buttons or purchase matching blanks. The latter gives you more control over the final diameter and back. Most cardigans look balanced with buttons measuring 15–20 mm, while a petite or children’s cardigan may suit smaller buttons. Check the actual dimensions in millimetres, as Australian sewing notions are commonly labelled that way.
The back style determines how the finished buttons will attach and how they will sit against the garment.
| Button blank | Back and attachment | Best cardigan choice | Main consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat covered blank | Two small sewing holes | Directly stitched or knitted bands | Very flat, but the reverse needs strong reinforcement |
| Shank button blank | Narrow plastic shank | Existing buttonholes and open-front cardigans | Strong and easy to align, with a small gap beneath the face |
| Covered-button kit | Rigid moulded back with holes | Quick, coordinated batches | Fast to assemble, though less soft behind |
For an existing buttonhole cardigan, shank blanks are usually the most practical choice. Their narrow stems pass cleanly through the opening and keep the fabric-covered faces flat. Flat blanks offer a completely different look and can be stitched directly to a knitted band, although the reverse needs more care and the button sits closer to the garment.
Count the buttonholes before buying anything, then add one spare blank. A spare is useful when a fabric placement goes wrong, and it prevents the set from feeling incomplete later. I also keep the online pattern reference bookmarked while planning so the garment measurements, chosen diameter and button spacing stay together in one research session.
Choose Fabric That Works with the Cardigan
Choose a stable, lightweight woven fabric for the most predictable result. Cotton, linen and viscose blends press well and can be moulded around a blank without stretching. A knit can work, but it may distort unless it is cut from a stable part of the garment and backed with lightweight interfacing. Very thick wool or bulky corduroy will create a heavy button that can pull against a fine cardigan.
The fabric relationship matters more than matching every colour exactly. A small print may read as a solid colour from across a room, while a large floral can become overwhelming when repeated across ten buttons. If the cardigan already has a print, select one motif from it and repeat that on every face. For striped knitwear, choose a solid coordinating colour or use the stripes to create an intentional directional pattern.
Australian climate and local stock can guide the choice. Light cotton is comfortable in Brisbane’s humid summer, while a wool or brushed cotton blend suits Melbourne’s cooler winter. Independent fabric shops often keep small offcut bundles behind the counter, and market stalls may sell remnants at useful prices. Wash and press the chosen fabric first, then use it while it is still slightly warm for easier shaping.
A smooth, non-stick pressing surface also helps. PVA craft glue works well because it dries clear and remains flexible, whereas thick hot glue can leave ridges behind the button. Fine-grit scissors, small tweezers, an awl, tailor’s chalk and a pressing cloth are useful additions to the sewing kit. Keep every blank and fabric piece labelled with its intended button position.
Cut and Shape the Button Covers
Measure the diameter of the blank itself rather than relying on the size printed on the packet. Place the blank on the fabric and trace around its outer edge. Add approximately 5 mm to the radius for the wrapping allowance, then cut the circle with sharp fabric scissors. If the blank includes a narrow flange, include that in the measurement and allow a little extra fabric around it.
Use the circle as a template for every piece so the finished set will be consistent. Mark the centre and a single grain or motif reference with a small chalk cross. This matters when the fabric carries a stripe, checks or scattered flowers, because shifting each piece by a few millimetres can make the finished row look uneven. Compare the marked pieces before cutting.
The edges of a circle need small clips so they can bend without creating pleats. Cut into the allowance at regular intervals, stopping before the traced line. For a woven fabric, pressing the circles first can help them curve more evenly, although the pressing cloth should protect delicate prints. Test one circle around a blank before preparing the rest if you are working with an unfamiliar fabric.
Backing adds control, particularly for flat buttons. Cut lightweight fusible interfacing to the same size as the inner portion of the blank and press it to the reverse of each fabric circle. For a related exercise in neat fabric handling, my fabric journal tutorial demonstrates how measured pieces and controlled edges make a pen loop sit neatly against a fabric-covered surface.
Wrap the Blanks for a Clean Finish
Squeeze a small amount of PVA glue into the concave back of the first blank and spread it evenly with a blunt stick or the end of a paintbrush. Avoid flooding the centre, as excess glue can soak through the fabric and create a dark ring. Position the fabric circle over the blank with the marked centre aligned to the middle.
Press the fabric into the recessed area using a fingertip or the rounded end of a tool. Work from the centre towards the outside, pushing out small wrinkles as you go. Fold the allowance around the back, keeping the edge tucked close to the rim. Add a second thin layer of glue only where the fabric lifts. The face should remain smooth, with no pleats running towards the centre.
Allow the piece to dry completely before handling it again. A quick-drying glue may feel firm after a minute but still be flexible underneath, so giving it time prevents the fabric from pulling away from the blank. Once dry, trim loose threads and check the back for gaps. Flat blanks can have a circle of interfacing added, while shank blanks should retain a clear, reinforced area around the stem.
Repeat the process and compare each button as the set grows. Hold them together in the planned order and rotate them under the light. A print should face the same way, the hems should sit at matching heights and the colours should remain balanced across the row. Replacing one imperfect cover at this stage is much easier than discovering the difference after sewing the entire cardigan.
Attach the Buttons and Test the Closure
Begin by laying the cardigan flat and marking the centre of every buttonhole with tailor’s chalk. Work from the bottom upwards so a slight change in spacing is easier to correct before reaching the neckline. Pin the first shank button at its mark, then compare its position with the remaining openings before sewing the rest.
To attach a shank button, use doubled strong thread. Pass the thread through the opening in the plastic shank from the inside of the cardigan, bring it through the buttonhole and return it through the shank. Repeat this sequence two or three times, keeping the stitches within the shank opening. The thread should hold the stem firmly without being visible across the button face.
A knitted cardigan without traditional buttonholes needs a different connection. Sew a small thread shank through the back of each flat covered button, forming a firm loop beneath it. Catch that loop around the edge or band of the cardigan, then sew through the loop and the back of the garment several times. This allows the front to open properly while keeping the covered face flat against the band.
Test each closure before moving on. Fasten the cardigan, check that the buttonholes remain centred and inspect the reverse for loose threads. Reinforce the first and last buttons with additional stitches if they carry more tension. Steam or press the garment lightly around the attachment points, taking care not to flatten the shank or distort the knitted band.
Style the Finished Cardigan and Keep the Process Visible
The completed set changes how the cardigan coordinates with the rest of a wardrobe. Tiny patterned covers can pick up the colours in a dress or scarf, while solid buttons create a restrained finish for work and everyday wear. For handmade gifts, add a short card explaining that the covers were cut and wrapped by hand. A wrapped pair of spare covers also makes a useful small present.
Documenting the batch can become part of the project itself. Photograph the fabric choices, the blank before wrapping and the final row once it is attached. Short process clips work well for showing how the fabric is pressed into the recess and how the thread shank is formed. I often share those stages on my YouTube channel and social media, where the close-up work is easier to follow than in a still image.
Finished projects can also head to local craft markets, where a coordinated cardigan stands out among machine-made clothing. Use a sturdy Australia Post padded envelope when posting a gift, and protect the buttons with a layer of tissue so they cannot mark the knit. Include care instructions that recommend gentle hand washing and drying the cardigan flat.
Choose the cardigan, measure its buttonholes and select one fabric in your favourite colour. Cut the first circle today, then build the remaining covers as an orderly set. When the last button is secure, wear the cardigan with pride and share the finished detail with your sewing community.